| | Player | Team | Year | Notes |
 | Paul Molitor | CHW | 2000 | Paul, a lifetime .305 hitter made his presents felt in the clubhouse and on the field. Elected to the Hall of Fame for his service with the Chicago White Sox he will ensure they are represented in the Hall though the team has moved on. |
 | Ryne Sandberg | FLA | 2000 | Ryno played for only 2 short years but proved to be a fan favorite. A Second Baseman for the Florida Marlins from 1997 to 1998. Ryno was inducted into the Hall of Fame by the managers in 2000. His stats were nothing to look at but his heart was felt by all. |
 | Albert Belle | STL | 2002 | Albert Belle was inducted into the FCBL Hall of Fame in 2002. Albert played for five seasons with the St. Louis Cardinals(Brian Cramer) and the Florida Marlins/San Francisco Giants(Cory Adams). Albert enters as a St. Louis Cardinal. |
 | Mark Mc Gwire | STL | 2003 | He played 6 seasons starting in Colorado(Cramer) where he won the MVP. Before the 1999 season he was traded to the Atlanta Braves(Erick) where he was on the back to back championship teams. He retired after the 2002 season. He will be wearing a St. Louis Cardinal hat (Cramer) |
 | Tony Gwynn | CLE | 2005 | Tony Gwynn played 6 seasons hitting .339 with Cleveland, Los Angeles, San Diego and finishing his career in Atlanta. He won World Series rings for Cleveland(Thome) in 1998 and Atlanta(Noland) in 2000. He enters the hall as a Cleveland Indian. |
 | Andres Gallaraga | STL | 2005 | Andres Galarraga played 6 seasons half of which for the Rockies/Cardinals franchise. He made stops in Boston and Anaheim before retiring with St. Louis in 2003. He will enter as a St. Louis Cardinal |
 | Edgar Martinez | STL | 2006 | Edgar Martinez played nine seasons starting in Cincinnatti, than moving on to Atlanta, St. Louis, Chicago, Minnesota and ended his career in St. Louis. He had similar seasons in Atlanta and St. Louis but winning a championship in St. Louis in 2004 helped him to decide to don a Cardinals hat for the hall. |
 | Robb Nenn | PIT | 2006 | Robb Nenn played seven seasons starting in Florida with Cory Adams stopping in Anhaeim for one season and ending his career in Pittsburgh with Cory Adams. The Pittsburgh franchise was also the New York Yankees before moving to Pittsburgh. He is the first pitcher inducted into the hall. |
 | Jeff Bagwell | HOU | 2007 | Jeff Bagwell was a constant image for the Houston Astros for 10 seasons. Drafted by Bryan Wayt in the 1997 and a good friend of Wayt's, Bagwell put up great numbers for the franchise. One of the few players to play his whole career for one team in the league. |
 | Larry Walker | STL | 2008 | Larry Walker has been inducted into the FCBL draft in 2008. Walker played 9 seasons. He played 4 seasons in Colorado/St. Louis under Manager Brian Cramer where he retired, 3 seasons in Boston with Sean Lamont and 2 seasons in Baltimore/San Diego with Katie Wayt. In 1998 Walker hit an amazing 66 HR for the Colorado Rockies. Larry will be wearing a Cardinals hat at the ceremony. |
 | Kevin Brown | BOS | 2008 | Kevin Brown will be inducted into the FCBL hall of fame this year. Kevin ended his career with a 129-66 record which puts him tied at 6th all time in wins as of the 2008 season. Kevin spent a majority of his career in Boston with manager Sean Lamont and led Sean to numerous division titles and appearances in the World Series in 1997 and 1998. Kevin will be the first player inducted from the original Boston Red Sox days when Sean Lamont was manager. |
 | Mike Piazza | DET | 2009 | Piazza was inducted in 2009 after playing 12 seasons in the FCBL. He will be inducted as a Detroit Tiger where he put up 4 yrs of awesome numbers including being HR champ in 2001. He won a World Series ring in 1999 with Detroit. He finished with a .306 avg, 1,580 hits, 258 doubles, 369 homeruns, drove in 1000 runs and finished with a .372 OBP%. He was an orginal 1st round pick of Brad Butler and the San Francisco Giants in 1997. |